written and posted by members of Lancashire Dead Good Poets' Society

Saturday, 5 December 2020

Netherworlds

Oh dear. Netherworlds is another theme that hasn't proved popular with the Dead Good blogging collective this week, but somebody has to boldly go there...


A while back, I posted a few commentaries on social media about the political tug-of-war that was developing in Belarus as the people of that country sought to oust via summer's 'democratic' elections the man they call "the last dictator in Europe". Lukashenko has been supreme leader of that country since 1994, making him the longest-serving political head of any European state. His party machine routinely rigs the vote in the polls every five years to ensure his comfortable victory. 

However, back in August of this year it became patently obvious not just to the international observers but to anyone with an ear and an eye that this time the popular vote in the Belarusian presidential and legislature election had gone convincingly against Lukashenko, so much so that many of his own party were embarrassed when he claimed he had won with an 80% share of the poll! 

Trump, of course, made similar victory claims three months later in the US presidential election. The difference between the two is that in the USA there was no large-scale vote-rigging and corruption in the counting halls (despite Trump's specious accusations), unlike in Belarus where Lukashenko cynically trashed the democratic process and then, because he is a dictator, in response to a country-wide outcry against the fixed result, ordered the troops and the secret police out onto the streets to arrest, beat up and  in some cases kill his political opponents, those who didn't flee into exile. 

The European Union has refused to recognise Lukashenko as the legitimate winner of the election and in a small irony, the USA has similarly refused. Three months down the line, the popular protests continue every week-end as do the beatings and imprisonment of opposition figures. Even the Russian foreign minister last week called for reforms in Belarus and Lukashenko has hinted that he may stand down at some unspecified point. (Ho hum.)

If you're wondering why I'm focusing on Belarus, it's because I feel immense sympathy for the people of that country, many of whom continue to live in a real-life netherworld, in large part because of what happened just ten miles across the border at  Pripyat, site of the Chernobyl nuclear power plant, on the morning of 26th April 1986.

One of the most powerful and frightening books I have read this year is 'Chernobyl Prayer' by the Belarusian writer and Nobel Literature Prize winner Svetlana Alexievich. Coincidentally, Alexievich was also a high-profile member of the political group known as the Co-ordination Council, set up to oppose the corrupt government of Lukashenko at the ballot box. She was the last of that group's leaders to flee into exile in Germany after Lukashenko had ordered her expulsion "alive or in bits". 

Everyone has heard of Chernobyl in Ukraine, (then, along with Belarus, a part of the USSR), for it was the scene of the worst nuclear catastrophe the world has known when, during a routine test to simulate recovery from an electrical power failure, the core of reactor #4 became unstable and exploded in an immense chain nuclear reaction, blowing the roof off the plant and hurling tonnes of radioactive material into the skies. The soviet authorities tried to drop lead sheets from helicopters to seal it, the lead just vaporised. They tried next with sand. The result was similarly unsuccessful, and all the while radioactive 'hot particles' of lead, sand and other contaminants were being spewed to the atmosphere. It took nine days to bring the fire under control. 

Chernobyl nuclear reactor #4 blows, 26th April 1986
Because of the prevailing wind at the time, clouds of radioactive dust swept north-west across Europe, being carried as far as Scandinavia, northern Britain and beyond into the Atlantic. Unfortunately for Ukraine's immediate neighbour, over 70% of the radioactive fall-out from that disaster landed on Belarus, rendering large swathes of the country uninhabitable, 20% of the agricultural land contaminated and two million out of its 10 million population affected in some way. 

'Chernobyl Prayer' tells the human side of the whole harrowing story in a series of powerful personal accounts from a cross-section of eye-witnesses: rescue workers, soldiers, medics, local politicians, ordinary people from the towns and villages most impacted in Ukraine and Belarus; people, many of whom knew they were dying from the effects of exposure, who wanted to testify to the world about the true nature of the horrors resulting from a major nuclear catastrophe. It's not for the faint-hearted, but I think it should be widely read as a dire warning.

On the assumption that probably most of you won't search out a copy (Penguin Modern Classics if you are interested), I will briefly summarise a few of the telling aspects of that netherworld here. For days no one was told of the danger, as hundreds of emergency forces tried to contain the disaster with a lack of proper protective gear. They were heroes. Most of them died in subsequent months, burned up inside from the effects of radiation. They were buried in lead-lined coffins with concrete poured in on top. After a while, the conscripted troops were shipped in to forcefully evacuate thousands of people from their towns and villages in the designated exclusion zone. They were told it was only a temporary move and they would soon be able to return. Few possessions and no pets were permitted on the evacuation buses. In fact no one was ever allowed home. The dogs and cats waiting patiently for their owners to come back, to feed them, were shot by specialist units, along with the abandoned livestock, horses, cows, pigs, chickens. In every deserted village these slaughtered animals were piled into deep pits and buried. Then the decontamination squads started chopping down all the trees, breaking up the deserted properties and removing the topsoil from towns and villages, farmers fields and common land. All of it had to be buried deep underground and covered with the earth that had been excavated to receive it. That freshly laid covering was only going to get contaminated in turn. For those living outside of the immediate exclusion zone, orders went out that they were not to drink the local water, nor eat fish from the rivers or any produce of their orchards and fields. Most of them disobeyed these instructions because 'everything looked fine and it would be a waste'. They underestimated the invisible enemy at their cost and hundreds of thousands have led painful and fore-shortened lives as a result. Even today in Belarus the disaster rolls on. A visiting international press corps was offered milk in a village. The journalists accepted the milk but didn't drink it, instead sent it to be analysed. It contained 100 times the safe level of background radiation. As mentioned earlier, 20% of the territory of Belarus is technically unfit to live in, although people do live there - what else to be done? - and that will be the case for hundreds of years. Meanwhile the official decontamination process continues, nearly thirty-five years after the explosion. That programme is scheduled to go on until the year 2065!

The astronomical cost of the remedial activities required in the aftermath of the Chernobyl disaster nearly bankrupted the USSR and was the single most important factor in the break-up of the Soviet Union within a decade of the catastrophe. What happened at Chernobyl changed the course of world history. It also gave Alexander Lukashenko, ex-Soviet border guard, the opening he had been looking for to rise to power in battered Belarus. Ukraine relied on funding from the EU and the UN to finance the building of the huge 'sarcophagus' that encloses the deadly ruins of reactor #4. Pripyat became a ghost city within an exclusion zone that won't be safe to live in for hundreds of years although bizarrely a niche trade has grown up in tours to the 'atomic Mecca'. It's an expensive ticket, for full radioactive hazmat clothing and respirators have to be worn and tourists have to undergo decontamination procedures afterwards. 

Chances of  a nuclear-free future are pretty non-existent, despite the catastrophes at Three Mile Island in the USA in 1979, Chernobyl as described above, or Fukushima in Japan in 2011. Our persistent arrogant belief that we won't cock it up makes us a dangerous species that threatens the viability of every other life-form on the planet; and worries only intensify as the likes of Iran and North Korea push ahead with their nuclear programmes. Only this week Iran's top nuclear scientist Mohsen Fakhrizadeh was assassinated in a targeted attack outside Tehran. No one has claimed responsibility but the smart money is on the Israeli secret service. Tensions in the middle east will only escalate and Nevil Shute's premise for 'On The Beach ', his 1957 post-apocalyptic novel about life on Earth being wiped out by a nuclear world war,  still looks uncomfortably prescient.

the crumbledust rubble of afterness
To conclude the account, this particular excerpt from 'Chernobyl Prayer ' will haunt me for a long time: "At the Academy of Sciences I was shown an X-ray of someone's lungs that had been burned through by 'hot particles'. They looked like the sky at night. The hot particles were microscopic pieces of radioactive material created when the burning reactor had lead and sand tipped into it. Atoms of lead, sand and graphite combined, and were shot high up into the atmosphere. They were dispersed over great distances, hundreds of kilometres. Now they were entering people's bodies via the respiratory tract. The highest mortality rate was among tractor and truck drivers, people who ploughed the land or drove along the dusty country roads. An organ in which these particles settle glows in X-rays. It is peppered with hundreds of tiny holes, like a fine sieve, The person affected dies, literally burns up; but whereas they are mortal, the hot particles live on. A person dies, and after a thousand years will have turned back into dust. The hot particles, though, are immortal, and their dust will be capable of killing again."

This week's poem on theme wasn't written about Chernobyl specifically, though it could have been. It is a more universal depiction of the aftermath of any apocalyptic event, like those accidents and wars that have wreaked havoc and misery in recent decades, or maybe something ominous waiting to happen in our precarious future. 

Blue Dust Time
The hour being on them once more
from crippled hospitals to gutted malls
dusk hunters dance a dextrous hex
stepping along sinister pavements
of doomed dreams, wanton schemers
kicking up the crunbledust rubble
of afterness searching out symbols
of the great before, any talisman left
more or less intact as they might
trade for one night of pain relief or
better still purchase a golden ticket
away from the poisonous dancefloor
of detritus. Cruel luck chuckles aloud
but simple magic moves this crowd
same blue dust time same avenues
same hunters same elusive prize
as all the days before and still to come
because for each lost and scary tribe
clinging on in homelands blighted 
beyond repair their fatal farandole
must go on. What else to be done?


By the by, this has been my 300th Saturday Blog. I call that a bit of a roll!

Thanks as ever for reading my stuff, S ;-)

46 comments:

Natalia Spencer said...

Good work Steve.

Miriam Fife said...

What an absolutely frightening account. I know fallout registered in parts of Scotland and there were scares about milk quality for a while.

Seb Politov said...

A sober read, but very well written.

terry quinn said...

A very powerful article and poem. Thank you for this Steve, And Congrats on the 300th.

Rod Downey said...

A brilliant precis. I always said you should have gone into investigative journalism or feature-writing. This made for very uncomfortable reading so I can only imagine what a whole book on the subject might be like. Your poem has the feel of a medieval dance of death about it. Well done on all counts.

F O'Jay said...

Oh Steve, this was most unsettling. We have enough to worry about with Covid and Brexit. More blogs about whisky and satyrs please! :)

Mac Southey said...

That's a hard-hitting read and your sentence about arrogant mankind being the most dangerous species is particularly apt as well as worrying. I thought the imagery and rhythm of your Blue Dust poem was immense.

Laxmiben Hirani said...

Awesome!!

Nigella D said...

Frightening and sad. The thought of all those pets waiting in vain for their owners to return :(

Stu Hodges said...

I suppose it has been such a sh!t year that people don't want to blog about anything remotely dark or threatening. Kudos to you for continuing to publicise difficult issues and for reaching a blogging milestone. That shows quite some dedication. This was another tremendous piece and the imagery of your dance-of-death poem is very powerful.

Ben Templeton said...

That's an incredible piece Steve. I never realised how severe and lasting an impact the disaster left, nor that it was the catalyst for the collapse of the old Soviet Union. Fascinating and awful to contemplate not just how bad it was but how much worse it might have been if they hadn't managed to contain the fire to the one reactor. Why had this not been more widely publicised?

Flloydwith2Ells said...

This is so good, Steve, congratulations, it's such a fine, articulate, coolly passionate exegesis. And Stu Hodges hit the nail on the head re your poem "dance of death" indeed.

Unknown said...

One of the scariest articles I have ever read. Well done for spotting it and writing about it

Charlotte Mullins said...

I'm left stunned by reading that. I don't know what else to say.

Mac said...

You brought the dread back.How we were scared we had been contaminated and the sheep and grass also.Then there was Windscale in the 50's.Well researched and written Steve. Mac

Tony Sedgwick said...

What you relate in your blog is truly shocking, as is the thought that it's an accident waiting to happen somewhere else. And that's not even taking into account all the radioactive waste from existing and decommissioned nuclear power stations that has to be stored for thousands of years as a source of potential contamination like boils on the surface of the planet.

Angela McG said...

Thank you for sharing your blog, and poem. I still remember 1986, I was in this country then, on a volunteer exchange programme, on a farm in Devon. When I returned to Germany in the summer, I was shocked to hear the facts about the disaster, most of which was not published in the UK. Our volunteer organisation in London told us about a law that meant that the government could prevent certain things from being published in the press, which may have been the Official Secrets Act, I guess. We had a cow and goats out in the fields, and used their milk in every meal, raw.

Brett Cooper said...

Excellent though chilling read and I was blown away by the language and rhythm of your poetry. As for Om The Beach, set right here in fair Melbourne city, of course, the human race ending with a whimper as they chomped their suicide pills. May it never come to pass!

Jon Cromwell said...

Oh boy! Okay, I've put Chernobyl Prayer on my Christmas list.

CI66Y said...

Well done Steve on hitting 300! I think I've read and enjoyed the majority of your blogs and this is another powerful piece and great poetry. Looking forward to your collection btw - what's the latest?

Debbie Laing said...

A brilliant piece and shocking to read. I love the poem.

Lizzie Fentiman said...

Congrats on your blogging milestone Steve. Keep going. Yours is one of the posts I read religiously every week for great writing. Blue Dust Time is a terrific poem.

Binty said...

Oh Steve. I was nearly in tears after reading this. It's all so horrifying and sad, but a brilliant blog.

Rochelle said...

Desperately sad Steve. I remember how we worried for a few weeks at the time it happened but we were never really told very much and I assumed it was all taken care of long ago. The revelations about the enormity of the damage and the fact it brought the Soviet Union to collapse are amazing to read. Your poem certainly fits the mood.

Deke Hughes said...

Powerful stuff indeed. You wrote a short poem about Lukashenko a few weeks ago but I can't find it now. It doesn't sound much fun being a Belarusian at the moment. Good luck to their revolution.

Bickerstaffe said...

Terrifying events. Of course we've had our own nuclear scares in the NW as well in the area around Windscale/Sellafield in Cumbria - rates of leukaemia way higher than the national average. I loved the dancing imagery of your polluted world poem.

Tom Shaw said...

You mentioned Three Mile Island and Fukushima so let me tell you about MUSE if you're not familiar with it. I know you're a fan of Jackson Browne, so you might know he was at the center of a musical collective Musicians United for Safe Energy that played awareness and fund-raising gigs for the anti-nuke movement in the wake of the 1979 disaster in Pennsylvania. A lot of my older muso friends used to talk about it, how they nailed their colors to the mast back in the day. Then in 2011 I got involved (though my connection with Jonathan Wilson) in a MUSE gig out on the West Coast to raise money for the Fukushima disaster relief fund. I'm totally with you on how dangerous this shit is Steve. It should be no part of a green world. Rock on.

Ross Madden said...

Jeez Steve, that was an emotional experience, but actually makes me want to go and read the book, which is a testament to your writing. An excellent blog and poem. 👏

Saskia Parker said...

OMG! Shocking to read, but what a brilliant blog and poem. 💙

Dan Francisco said...

That's a fearsome account there Steve. I read some of the comments including the one about MUSE. I was at that 2011 benefit gig at the Shoreline Amphitheater in Mountain View CA. Great post-apocalyptic riff of a poem.

Steve Rowland said...

Deke: here's the poem I wrote for national poetry day. It's called

Party Over!

Lukashenko.
Bastard son of the USSR,
border-guard mutated into
'last dictator in Europe',
your very name sounds
like a prison, dark, scary,
repressive.

You may crank up the old
state karaoke machine
and sing
it's my party and I'll
pry if I want to
spy if I want to
try if I want to...

but no one believes your song
will last for long now.

Oleg Doleev said...

Three Mile Island and Chernobyl were completely different scale disasters. Yes Three Mile Island should have acted as warning but it was only cat. 5, some localized irradiated gas escape, no related deaths and cost $1 billion to clean up. Chernobyl was cat.7, massive and protracted discharge of irradiated matters, thousands of direct related dearhs and cost $235 billion to clean up in first years. Work still continues as you stated. Scary truth is it was nearly many time worse.

Myra DeJonge said...

I have read this book Chernobyl Prayer and I confirm what an exceptional writing that every person should read.

Francesca Marrone said...

A brilliant blog and a warning to us all not to be carless about nuclear power. I watched a documentary about Chernobyl on Italian TV and one image has haunted me ever since. A radiologist told of visiting a village in Belarus months after the disaster. She was surprised to see a young woman in the village (most had been evacuated as you describe) just sitting outside her house breastfeeding her baby. She tested the woman's breast milk. It was radioactive. She called her the Madonna of Chernobyl.

Howie Schroeder said...

Brilliantly penned but quite terrifying. No wonder Oppenheimer had sleepless nights.

Alex Tsimbalist said...

There was much discrimination of 'Chernobyl' people after evacuation to other towns. New neighbours were nervous. Parents struggled to get jobs and make friends. Children were called 'glow worms; at school. Nearly all got sick. In Belarus abortions increase from 20,000 each year to 200,000. Such was bad times. Chernobyl changed so much overnight.

Alistair Bradfield said...

The world rightly concentrates on Chernobyl because it is the worst nuclear plant disaster (to date) but those of us living in the north-west of England know all about Windscale (now renamed Sellafield) in Cumbria. It was the biggest nuclear plant in the world when it opened in 1950 and it was the scene of the first major accident when fire broke out in one of its reactors in 1957 leaking radioactivity into the local area. The degree of danger was hushed up at the time but the damaged reactor was 'sealed' for 30 years and only opened up in the 1980s so decontamination could commence. Windscale closed as a nuclear power station over a decade ago but the decommissioning if the site is scheduled to last for a hundred years and will cost £120 billion - just read those last statistics again. The immense cost of decommissioning is never a feature when the economics of providing nuclear power are discussed and that is a disgraceful deception being practised again right now as new nuclear plants are planned in England.

Harry Lennon said...

That's a powerful and disturbing blog containing some painful truths. You've attracted some great comments as well. What I particularly like about your poem (if I read it right) is the way that the victims of this disaster of sophisticated technology fall back on magic, superstition and tribalism. It's a fatalistic response, a reversion to primitivism after an epic failure of the rational, brilliantly portrayed.

Jade Keillor said...

Dreadful to read your powerful blog and all the comments. Why did we ever think we could safely harness something as destructive as nuclear fission and the unstable waste that results? An arrogance that beggars belief, as you stated.

Anonymous said...

I've been quietly enjoying your Saturday blogs for a few years. Well done on reaching 300 and thank you for keeping it all going. This latest, like so many others, is seriously good.

Steve Rowland said...

Thank you all for your feedback and additional observations. I know it's a difficult topic but I hope the issue resonates - and Harry, you're spot on. I'd like to quote one last long paragraph from Chernobyl Prayer just in case anyone reads this far down into the comments:
"There was a moment when there was a real risk of a nuclear explosion, and it was essential to drain the ground water beneath the reactor so it wouldn't be reached by a molten mix of uranium and graphite which, coming into contact with the water, would achieve critical mass. The power of the resultant explosion would have been three to five megatons. Not only would Kiev and Minsk have been wiped out, but an enormous area of Europe would have been made uninhabitable, a catastrophe on a European scale. The situation required volunteers to dive into the water and open the latch on the drainage valve. They were promised a car, an apartment, a dacha, and a pension for their families to the end of their days. Volunteers came forward! The boys dived, repeatedly, and managed to open the latch. That is why we are still here - though those people are no longer with us."

Bridget Durkin said...

That's maybe the most powerful post I've read all year. Covid pales by comparison. I've just ordered the Chernobyl Prayer book. Thank you.

Natalija Drozdova said...

Such a powerful blog and a reminder how dangerous all things nuclear can be. I fear more disasters of this kind.

Jake Morrison said...

An awful testament but a brilliant piece of writing and a haunting poem.

Ali Firsova said...

Have you read any of the poetry of Belarusian poet Valzhyna Mort? Well worth checking out: https://www.valzhynamort.com

Elise Curzon said...

I was shocked to read this. We never knew Chernobyl had been so calamitous and so nearly very much worse. Your poem of the lost tribe is brilliant.