written and posted by members of Lancashire Dead Good Poets' Society

Saturday, 21 December 2024

Disappearing Act

I wasn't sure how I would tackle this topic. I was favouring a piece about the mysterious disappearance of Agatha Christie in December 1926. But then last week I got locked out of Facebook for days, and I knew I had my angle.

I've no idea why I was locked out. One day Facebook was working fine, the next when I put in my id and password (I was using my laptop by the way) I got a screen I'd never seen before, telling me that an access code was being sent to my WhatsApp account. I checked regularly for half an hour but nothing arrived. I tried logging into Facebook on my iPhone only to meet the same screen, promising a code to my WhatsApp account but again nothing arrived. I logged off from all applications, switched off laptop and phone, rebooted my router and tried once more a few hours later. Same issue, still no access.

I'm a patient sort of guy and I knew from my daily BBC newsfeed that Facebook was experiencing some problems with all the applications on its Meta platform, so I decided to leave it until the next day to try again. I met exactly the same result, or more accurately, lack of result. This time when the promised code didn't arrive to my WhatsApp account I logged off and on again and took Facebook's 'Try Another Way' option. The alternative they promised me was to send an SMS code to my iPhone... and guess what? Nothing arrived. 

Naively I thought I might have been locked out of my account for 24 or 48 hours. I've heard of this happening, but I believed people usually got some notification as to the reason for it happening. All I had was a faceless nothing.

However, when Facebook failed to rise again on the third day, I must admit I began to feel like a character in some absurd existential Kafkaesque nightmare who doesn't know what he's done wrong, doesn't have any way of contacting the authority responsible for excommunicating him, and has no idea if this state of affairs is temporary or permanent. I was trying, and failing, to deal with Facelessbook!

from Franz Kafka's sketchbook (1901-1907) courtesy National Library of Israel, Jerusalem
I know the use of the platform is not as common or fashionable as it once was, but I do use it regularly to communicate with my 1,400 Facebook friends on a personal level as well as acting as supporters' liaison officer for Blackpool FC and as admin for a few Facebook groups, including Lancashire Dead Good Poets' Society, Fans United and Love My Greece. 

In fact I've been using it more, if anything, since I withdrew from Twitter/X (now Musk has made that such a toxic platform), so being 'disappeared' from social media was quite a serious issue. 

In a further bizarre twist, after I couldn't access my account for a few days I began getting emails from Facebook telling me that X people had liked certain posts, Y people had commented on others and that I had various messages waiting from Z friends - as though Facebook thought that I was neglecting it, and was sending me gentle reminders not to forsake it - while still promising, every time I tried to log in, to send me an access code which simply never arrived!

On the evening of the third day, I decided to go the route of re-validating who I was. This involved logging onto a separate Meta application and uploading as proof of identity a scan of either my passport or my driving licence. I opted for the latter. It came back and told me that my ID could not be verified.

Of course I thought this was completely bonkers and began to contemplate the possibility of having to set up a brand new Facebook account from scratch for personal use - but then I didn't know where that would leave the groups and pages for which the 'disappeared'  Steve Rowland is supposedly responsible, and I even foresaw the possibility of being told I couldn't set up a new Steve Rowland account because one already existed.

I decided to give it one more day - and lo and behold on the fourth day when I tried to log onto Facebook I received the following screen:


All I had to do was click on 'Yes, This Was Me'  who had sent them ID, you remember, the one that they said could not be verified), and I was back into all my accounts like nothing had happened, with no further explanation. 

Had some fiendish interloper really tried to log into my account? What made them think it wasn't me? Had they really locked my account? If so, why did they say (on several occasions) they were sending me access codes which never arrived, and why did they keep on emailing me about comments and messages they thought I would like to see? Finally, why did they tell me they could not verify the ID I sent them only to ask a day later if it was genuinely from me? None of it makes any sense, nor does it fill me with confidence that their security software actually hangs together. But what can you do (apart from write a blog about it)?
 
Those of you who know anything about Franz Kafka (1883-1924) and have maybe read any of his small but influential body of work (he destroyed 90% of what he wrote), will have understood why I used the term Kafkaesque in relation to my recent Facebook experience. His novels and short stories are pervaded by a sense of alienation and the absurd, of typically isolated, bemused and often terrified protagonists facing bizarre predicaments, often at the hands of some remote and incomprehensible socio-bureaucratic power.

Of course I personally wasn't terrified by this recent disappearing act, because it posed no real existential threat, but it was mighty annoying. At least it gave me the idea for this poem as I wondered how Kafka might have handled the situation. Maybe the title is the best thing about it. Think of it as a first sketch that I might work up into something more substantial in due course, given time.  

Franz Kafka's Facebook Meltdown

This is not felicitous.

I only do Facebook 
to prove to myself
that I still exist but you have
plucked my wings
and my words go nowhere.

What was my misdemeanour,
the ugly truth of which I alone
am unaware? I sense cold flames
beneath the floorboards and
my empty hours feed paranoia.

Is this cyber Metastasis
or a singular targeted and
punitive privation? If so.
to whom may I make my appeal?
Is anyone investigating my case?

Vengeance is mine, says the void.







Thanks for reading, S ;-)

19 comments:

Yvonne said...

How frustrating!

Anonymous said...

Laxmiben Hirani
Social media what can I say! Is very frustrating in every sense.

Mac Southey said...

Bloody annoying trying to deal with the likes of FB. I like the poem as it is.

Billy Banter said...

Welcome back! 😃

Lizzie Fentiman said...

I love that quote from the 60s 'Just because you're paranoid doesn't mean they're not out to get you'. Great blog, promising poem. Keep going Steve. Merry Christmas and HNY to you.

terry quinn said...

What a nightmare disappearing act.
But as a proper writer you seized the moment.
'Cold flames beneath the floorboards'

Pam Winning said...

What a nightmare! I'm glad it's all sorted. Great blog.

Ailsa Cox said...

Scary. I never joined Facebook (as teachers we were recommended not to have social media accounts) but I can imagine how frustrating this must have been for you. Good poem (and yes, great title).

Debbie Laing said...

I've not read anything by Kafka but your description of his vision of the world certainly fits and I think it's a good poem. What annoys me most about Facebook is all the unsolicited advertisements. It's really becoming a business forum now, isn't it?

Ross Madden said...

"Is this cyber Metastasis?" Clever! 👏

Anonymous said...

Bah, Facebook!

Grant Trescothick said...

Facebook has been getting dodgier lately - that's the ugly truth. Your experience is not uncommon, unfortunately.

Jen McDonagh said...

Faceless book! Ha ha ha. Pleased for you that your time in the sin bin is over. At least you got a good poem out of it.

Deke Hughes said...

As flies to wanton boys are we to the Facebook bots!

Seb Politov said...

I saw that Zuckerberg has announced Facebook(Meta) is going to dismantle its content moderating operation in the USA. Might be harder to do in Europe. I liked the Kafka parallels.

Gemma Gray said...

I've not given up on Facebook yet but I did get out of X last year and set up a bluesky profile instead. Clever of you to invoke the Kafkaesque nature of your Facebook exile.

Jon Cromwell said...

I've never contravened FB's community standards but I have got increasingly annoyed with all the adverts in my feed. Strange that they didn't say why you had been suspended. However, you got a good poem out of it! As you say, it's a cracking title.

Kate Eggleston-Wirtz said...

Scary and frustrating - Metastasis indeed - it's spreading to other platforms - and one can never talk to a person that would resolve issues in like 20 seconds. Glad you are back online. Clever poem.

Darren Wilkes said...

Very good. Written with style as well as bite. (I loved " when Facebook failed to rise again on the third day".) What an inspired idea to draw the Kafka parallel, it's a great poem.