written and posted by members of Lancashire Dead Good Poets' Society

Saturday 13 November 2021

Ridiculous?

Another Saturday Blog deadline goes to the wire even as COP26 negotiations are trundling to a less than successful conclusion in Glasgow. The latter is hardly surprising when the two biggest polluters, China and the USA, backed up by India, refuse to sign up to hard and fast targets for reducing fossil fuel usage and Saudi Arabia, the biggest oil producer, similarly skewers attempts to set effective goals for ramping down oil production. 

Okay, China and the USA may have come up with a bilateral agreement to tackle global warming issues together - but don't be fooled, that is mostly a PR exercise. Behind the scenes, the USA actually plans to increase its mining and consumption of coal in the coming years; and who knows what the Chinese intend, as their plans are secret. Even the UK, hosting this latest world symposium, refused to sign up to the fossil fuel phase-out target which the science insists is necessary to reverse our rush towards climate catastrophe. Hugely disappointing all round. COP out, one might say.

I've blogged about various aspects of the climate crisis several times over the last five years, but I'm going to spare us all another blah blah blast this evening. Instead I've been tracking one of the more improbably bizarre but constructive attempts to provide green alternatives to our destructive lifestyle. How would you like to print your own meat? Ridiculous? Read on...

sizzling steak on the grill
It seems to be the case that the world and his dog loves a juicy steak, burger, or roast beef feast, often washed down with a milkshake or followed by a dish of ice-cream.  Even 60% of the menu available to the COP26 delegates was based on animal and dairy products! There's a revealing graphic at the bottom of today's blog that highlights the volume of greenhouse gas emissions from animal and plant based foods - scroll down for a quick check now and you'll note that beef production is by far the largest of all, with cow's milk coming in a close third, making the two cow-based items combined way more significant as sources of emissions than anything else.

I was looking into the progress that's been made to date with bringing vegan, plant-based versions of bacon and sausages to market when I stumbled upon the concept of 'novameat' and a novel way of manufacturing it to resemble as closely as possible the texture and taste of a beef steak.

We are all now familiar with the concept of 3-D printers being able to 'print' quite complicated pieces of kit by using plastic and resin instead of ink in the printer jets, building up workable objects in a layering process driven by computer programs. Some high-tech companies, mainly in the USA and Israel, have taken the idea to another level by developing liquids and spraying algorithms that can be used to replicate edible products - ersatz beef and pork steaks among them. I'll repeat. Ridiculous? Take a look at this...

3-D meat printing in action
Instead of inks, the nozzle jets spray out lines of tasty protein to build up a product that has both the fibrous texture of meat, but also the look, colour and taste before and after cooking. It's still a very expensive option, still niche and still being enhanced, but like all innovations it will become cheaper over time and who knows, one day all restaurant kitchens will feature 3-D printers as part of their standard equipment...and we may even see domestic versions nestling next to the microwave.

Of course, that's going to be of no immediate consolation to the swathes of the world with barely enough food for their families today and no kitchen to prepare it in. Which leads into my latest poem, anticipating the COP after next in 2023 when I'm supposing things will only have got worse. Again, probably not the finished article as it was written as the clock ticked down, but here it is (edit: now with revisions after discussion with my Stanza buddies).

From Printer To Plate at COP28
The kitchen's 3-D printers have been
working overtime so ruthless leaders 
of the world can dine on grilled meat
that never knew a cow, washed down
by a wine of rare vintage from a land
already drowned by rising seas. Still 

a minute off midnight, still too much
hot air, not just inside the dining hall.
And everywhere, secret oil wells and
illicit beef farms for the few; poison,
famine, searing fires and inundations
from swollen oceans for the many. It

is funny how the science can warn us
and technology provides alternatives,
yet unless there is an obvious means
of getting something on the cheap or
making a killing out of it, then a will
to change is sadly lacking. Supposing

tonight I were one of the poor waiters,
refugees from devastated states, I'd be 
longing to hi-jack the damned printers 
and hack two hundred humane hearts,
that we might best transplant empathy
into the cynical, self-satisfied old farts.


Should it be the end of the road for the friendly cow? What are your thoughts?

Thanks for reading, S ;-)

35 comments:

Sophia Mapano said...

Jaw-dropping technology. Who ever would have thought? And a brilliant poem. Well said. 💚

Rod Downey said...

Wow. I thought you were spoofing us to begin with but I've queried the net and yes 3-D printed meat is a thing. Sorry for doubting you. It's certainly a good candidate for Ridiculous (with a query), just as the big boys at COP have been Ridiculous (with an exclamation) in their refusal to concede on their stubborn slowness to decrease dependence on fossil fuels. I think your poem is pretty good as it stands, but I know that amendments to drafts are all the rage right now (LOL).

Anne Ward said...

Don't want any.

Jen McDonagh said...

Well that was certainly interesting. I'm not sure about appetising though. I thought the poem was clever and thought-provoking. As for the cow, if the science is to be followed it doesn't have a great future, does it?

Ross Madden said...

Certainly food for thought there Steve. I really liked your poem: great title, clever scenario, some fabulous lines and I definitely wasn't expecting that last verse. 👏

Ben Templeton said...

It's like Tomorrow's World (whatever happened to that?) and if people need to eat meat then much better fake meat than real beef. So I'm all for it. Your poem is poignant (especially that vintage wine "from a land already drowned by rising seas"). It prompted me to look up where COP28 will be held - that will be in Abu Dhabi in two years' time.

Mary Jane Evans said...

Well that's an interesting concept, and keeps the pleasure of eating 'meat' without paying the ecological price, though I'm sure it's not cheap. It's a great poem too.

Boz said...

Fascinating blog, justifiably pointed poem, revealing graph. Phase out the cow now ;)

Debbie Laing said...

I don't like the idea of printed steaks or chops. If we're going to give up eating real beef then why not eat something else that's real - lots of fabulous vegetarian recipes out there. Why go to all the trouble and expense of making something that's not meat look and taste like meat? I just don't get it. But I love how your COP28 poem has run away with the idea of 3-D printing. It's funny and clever and sad. Well done.

Lizzie Fentiman said...

You know my government's line on this. They fiddle and burn, in hock to the bloody coal mines. We're on course for too little, too late despite everything.

Lydia Glezou said...

I'm sure it will happen but this is a capitalist solution (rich man's tech for rich people's pleasure) and not the sort of radical social solution to how to feed the world's expanding population without decimating the planet. Your poem is good, though. 👍

Ailsa Cox said...

Food for thought, right enough. I liked your clever poem and I'm sure the technology is amazing but I have no sympathy with the steak munchers. Why do they consider a grilled lump of dead animal any more aesthetic than a dish of roast vegetables or pulses? It's just habit. As for cattle, I think their numbers will have to ramp down significantly.

Grant Trescothick said...

Interesting reading. The graph is telling - air travel quite sizeable. I'm sure ways can be found to make cleaner planes but it will be difficult to stop cattle producing methane so I would say yes, end of the road for massive herds. What a great poem, too. 👏

Chloe Tudor said...

That's amazing. But surely the money could be spent more wisely. I loved your clever poem.

Peter Fountain said...

Totally agree with your take on COP26. 3-D printed meat sounds ridiculous but the truth is clearly stranger than fiction. If an eco-tax were levied on real meat products then novameat might become cost-effective but right now it looks to be about 10 times as expensive as the real thing. I think that's a great poem.

Deke Hughes said...

Thanks for sharing this Steve. It's another powerful and professionally written piece. Printed beefsteak does sound ridiculous but if it takes away an excuse for eating (and farming on industrial scale) beef cattle then it must be a positive step however unlikely the concept. Your poem impressed for many reasons, not least because you end each stanza with what is logically the first word of the succeeding stanza. Clever effect.

Jambo said...

Sound that. 👏

Saskia Parker said...

Thank you Steve, that was interesting and quite shocking. I'm thinking of giving up meat but I feel no need of the fake variety. I thought your clever COP28 poem was a wonderful notion.

Writer21 said...

No, it isn't very impressive is it?

Nevertheless, breakfast outlets are making an effort to provide vegan options inc. Vegan bacon and vegan sausage,- which is a step forward.

I agree with your comment about the USA.

Idon't think that beef will be totally phased out because farmers need tonmake a living.

It was an amazing read though about the wonders of technology- it sounded like sci-fi.

The last verse of your poem has impact abd engages the emotions.

Thank you.


Nigella D said...

You're so right about cynical and self-satisfied rulers. If only transplants was the answer! A clever and moving poem. The thought of fake meat is too awful though.

Billy Banter said...

Cows out! Cows out! Cows out!

Gareth Boyd Haskins said...

Good call regarding the recent COP-out. The 3-D printer stuff is interesting, but surely niche for now. I liked your pointed COP28 poem though. Well said.

Anonymous said...

The carnivore is over :)

Jay Henderson said...

3-d printer meat sounds a bit indulgent, like those steaks covered in gold foil. I really liked your clever COP28 poem though.

Jenny Grant said...

I found the whole concept of 3-D printers a challenge a few years ago, that anyone could print out a plastic hip joint or a working cogwheel. It just seemed incredible. Now I'm prepared to believe that printers can create fake meat that can pass for the real thing but it feels indulgent compared to working parts. Still, who knows?

Anonymous said...

This is fascinating - but paints a picture of a future world of eating I want no part of. Long live 'real' food!

Simon Pickford said...

Yes, another COP out. I loved the poem. Well done for that.

Binty said...

Fantastic blog. Printed 'meat' sounds so improbable. I loved your COP28 poem, so imaginative. I wonder how the methane emissions from 'old farts' would rate on the scale? 👏

Dan Francisco said...

It was a real pisser to realise that the multi-million dollar lobbying campaigns of coal, oil and gas interests shafted the attempts of those countries on the front line of the impending disaster to get the world to wise up now. I am deeply angered and ashamed by my own government even though we are not supposed to be climate-change deniers now we've got shot of Trump.

Mark II Ford said...

Very good response to a disappointing COP. I really like the poem. 👏

Brad Marino said...

The whole thing is ridiculous, isn't it. I loved the clever poem. Spot on, that man.

Hitesh Popat said...

I liked the few and many comparison in your dystopian poem and the crazy but lovable dream of the last verse. Things will never get better for some. The cynical self-satisfied old farts are too entrenched.

Bruce Paley said...

Chicken and rice combined nearly as bad as beef! Maybe the answer is to reduce world population. Ridiculous to suggest global warming is a mechanism to achieve that end? Just a provocative thought.

Bridget Durkin said...

Well said Steve. Too little too late from every COP to date. China, Russia and USA in particular playing geopolitical poker with the fate of the planet.

Anonymous said...

What a great poem - nails the real issue as to why insufficient progress is made.