I've chosen instead to highlight a different and more recent three days that changed the world, namely The Beatles' appearances on the Ed Sullivan Show. We can be precise about those dates: not three consecutive days, but three consecutive Sundays: 9th, 16th and 23rd February 1964. In light of John Lennon's 'infamous' remark from a couple of years later of The Beatles being "more popular than Jesus now" (more on that below), I thought it an interesting parallel to draw.
The Ed Sullivan Show aired on CBS every Sunday night and was at the time the most popular American entertainment programme with an average audience of 24 million viewers. Brian Epstein, manager of The Beatles, knew that if his group was to 'break' America, then exposure on the medium of the moment was necessary. The Beatles' early singles had not taken off in the States. EMI's US subsidiary had passed on the opportunity to release them. 'Love Me Do' got ignored completely and 'Please Please Me', 'From Me To You' and 'She Loves You' were licenced out to small independent labels and sank without trace.
Finally Epstein managed to persuade EMI's subsidiary Capitol to release the next one 'I Want To Hold Your Hand' at the end of 1963 as a lead-in to the television appearances he had negotiated. By the beginning of February 1964 'I Want To Hold Your Hand' had hit the top of the US charts and a week later The Beatles were performing live on the Ed Sullivan Show to an estimated audience of 73 million people (nearly half the viewing nation) - a ratings record and a generation-defining event. Urban myth has it that crime statistics for the night were the lowest for years. Their second appearance the following Sunday attracted nearly as big an audience of 71 million viewers and those two programmes are still in the top three all time tv audiences in the USA, being surpassed only in 1983 by the final episode of M*A*S*H. The third appearance on 23rd February didn't draw quite so big an audience as by then half the teenagers in the country were in their garages forming Beatle-inspired pop groups!
The Beatles as first seen by millions on US tv screens |
That last point was not an entirely facetious one. In the wake of the shock of President Kennedy's assassination less than three months earlier, the USA had been in something akin to a collective depression, a state of mourning and disorientation that sucked the joy out of life and sapped the nation's natural optimism. Those appearances by The Beatles on the Ed Sullivan Show single-handedly (OK, eight-handedly) gave the country its joy back, lifting not just teen spirits from coast to coast. The nation went into catch-up mode and within a month The Beatles held the top five spots in the US Billboard singles chart (those earlier 45s finally getting airplay and sales), another record that's never been broken. Young Americans did form bands directly as a result of seeing The Beatles. They also got caught up in the whirlwind of Beatlemania, bought the merchandise, grew their hair, became less parochial in outlook, and made almost a religion out of their fascination with the group and its music - and that embrace of The Beatles by America was what catapulted them to global fame and changed the world for the better in the process. So had they really become "more popular than Jesus"?
What John Lennon actually said, in an interview with Maureen Cleave of the Evening Standard in March 1966, was: "Christianity will go. It will vanish and shrink. I needn't argue about that; I'm right and I'll be proved right. We're more popular than Jesus now; I don't know which will go first - rock'n'roll or Christianity. Jesus was all right but his disciples were thick and ordinary. It's them twisting it that ruins it for me." His remarks were mis-quoted and misinterpreted in the American press which led to a series of Beatle-record bonfire events in the southern bible belt at the start of the group's final US tour, a temporary blip on their staggering rise to unparalleled planetary fame and popularity.
Okay, in complete contrast to the happy vibe of Beatlemania, I offer my second poem catalysed by the wicked war being waged by Putin in Ukraine - another event with a claim to having changed the world in the last few weeks.
Of all the Ukrainian cities Putin has targeted to date, the southern Black Sea port of Mariupol has been the hardest hit, pounded relentlessly by Russian artillery and surrounded by advancing Russian troops. The majority of its buildings have been destroyed, the civilian population has been living for weeks in cellars and basements, without electricity or running water. Thousands have been allowed to flee along occasional humanitarian corridors and the stories they tell are heart-rendingly awful. Thousands more have been killed in what clearly constitutes the worst war crime in Europe since WW II. Thousands remain trapped, starving, facing an uncertain fate in what has been described as "hell on earth" Ukrainian forces have been holding out bravely but are short of ammunition and it is feared Mariupol is about to be the first city since the invasion to fall into Russian control.
bullet-riddled Mariupol city sign |
Easter In Mariupol
No eggs this Easter in Maria's city,
not a chicken left alive. And God,
where is he to be found today? In
the thin smile of a starving child
clutching a dirty rag rabbit? Maybe,
for innocence has a power to touch
even a steely heart toting an AK-74,
a soldier and orphan holding hands
in the starkness of this earthly hell.
Hope treads on fragments of shells.
As a musical Easter egg, here's a link to Julian Lennon singing his father's famous song for the first time in public recently at a concert for Ukraine. Click on the title to play: Imagine
Thanks as ever for reading my stuff, S ;-)
51 comments:
As a fellow fanatic, how can I not second your choice of world-changing event(s)? Though of course we loved them before they hit the big time in the USA ;) And it's a great Ukraine poem, Steve, as powerful in its way as your first.
Oz declared early for the Beatles too. They came over in June 1964, played in Adelaide, the Festival Hall here in Melbourne and Sydney. Eight concerts in all. It seems like ancient history now but my parents still talk about it. Fans turned out in their hundreds of thousands. here's a 25-minute newsreel on YouTube if you haven't seen it: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=1aU8Of01izY
Wow! Your poem... ๐๐
An interesting read as always. Your poem is very moving. It seems Mariupol is still refusing to surrender today. Thanks for the link to Julian Lennon singing 'Imagine' - it's spine-tingling.
He is in the lives of all who have escaped persecution and has taken home those that have been taken by the senseless violence. He is alive in all of this madness though it may not seem so. He never walks away from us. He is in those who give their lives selflessly, those who provide cover and medical aide. I pray for those I do not know, for they are my brothers and sisters in Christ.
Interesting and provocative blogging. Lennon's statement is probably as controversial now as it was in 1966. He may well be right about the Beatles being more popular than Jesus but he obviously erred when he speculated that Christianity would vanish. And what would he have made of the rise of religious fundamentalism (regardless of creed)? I think your poem is very good but surely you meant AK-47?
No, Tim. I did mean AK-74 as written - weaponry has moved on. The one thing I wasn't sure about in the poem was the image of soldier and the child hand-in-hand. It was meant to signify humanity in the face of evil, but there is a rumour that the invaders have taken hundreds of children from Mariupol and shipped them off to Russia (which sounds like abduction).
Well done with the evocative poetry Steve. What's happening in Mariupol is a both a crime and a tragedy.
What a lovely poem. ๐ I get where you're coming from with the Beatles piece. Also, great to hear Julian Lennon - sounds so much like his father.
The Beatles are certainly more popular than Christianity with me. Like Lennon said, Jesus was all right but organized religion sucks. Look at all the religious wars there have been. Your poem is poignant. As in Homs and Idlib, so in Mariupol - indiscriminate Russian pulverising of the civilian population.
As a 14 year old crew-cut American kid, those Beatles appearances on Ed Sullivan changed the course of my life (and millions like me). They were a revelation. A door to a different future opened right there.
Beatlemania was slightly before my time but there's no denying the impression that the whole world has fallen in love with them and stayed that way. As for what's happening in Ukraine, that will also change the world, not necessarily for the better. It depends where Putin's persecution complex takes him.
It's a fragile and resonant poem. I have to admire your optimism.
I grew up with the Beatles: I was 12 when their first single was released. And always loved them. However, the full John Lennon quote you gave merely reinforces what a dogmatic and egocentric individual he was. Anyone who insists "I'm right and I'll be proved right" should be treated with at least one pinch of salt. He was a great songwriter, particularly when collaborating with Paul McCartney and one of his songs - "You've Got To Hide Your Love Away" - spoke to those of us who at the time were growing up gay in a country where expressing our love was a crime. I admit I found his solo work uneven - ranging from amazing work like "Give Peace a Chance", "Whatever Gets You Through the Night" and "Mind Games" to appallingly self-indulgent stuff like "How Do You Sleep", "God" and the whole of the "Sometime In New York City" album (great politics but crap songs). I have never liked "Imagine", partly because of the way it links faith with war. Paul McCartney's solo work has, in my view, been much stronger and consistent than John's.
Kevin, thanks for the considered reply, much appreciated. I think Lennon was forthright (some may say opinionated) and not always as carefully articulate as his song-writing partner, but I've always preferred his work, perhaps because he had more edge, more of the poet about him than did McCartney. (And I quite like the energy and immediacy of 'Some Time In New York City'.)
The Beatles did change the world - and your 3 day Ed Sullivan shout seems a reasonable one - they had to conquer America in order to gain global prominence (just like they had to leave Liverpool for London in order to gain national prominence). That's how things worked in the 1960s.
I thought your Mariupol poem with its Easter imagery of eggs, shells, hope for rebirth was both sensitive and moving.
Such a beautiful, heart-rending poem.❤️
I used to talk with my older brother Rick about this when he was still with us, a huge Beatles fan. He claimed he remembered seeing those shows as a kid. I was too young. Then there was that Beatles movie A Hard Day's Night and their music, which everyone flipped for. I remember reading someplace that The Byrds formed after the guys all watched them on Ed Sullivan or the movie. It was definitely a big thing.
A lovely poem for a difficult time. ๐
Lennon was a seeker after truth and quite widely read. At the time of that Evening Standard interview he had just read 'The Passover Plot' by Hugh Schonfield (a British biblical scholar, published in 1965) and that possibly informed his views on Christianity.
According to Schonfield's analysis, the events of the Passover, which are presented in all the Gospels, but inconsistently, are most accurately presented in the Gospel of John. His reading of that Gospel convinced him that John's account, though probably filtered through an assistant and transcription in John's old age, suggests that Jesus had planned everything. Among other things, so that he would not be on the cross for more than a few hours before the Sabbath arrived when it was required by law that Jews be taken down, so that one of his supporters, who was on hand, would give him water (to quench his thirst) that was actually laced with a drug to make him unconscious, and so that Joseph of Arimathea, a well-connected supporter, would collect him off the cross while still alive (but appearing dead) so that he could be secretly nursed back to health - meaning the 'resurrection' was faked in order to create a religious cult around Jesus. The book was made into a film of the same name in the 1970s.
I can perfectly understand how you wanted to leaven the bleakness of what has befallen Mariupol, and your poignant Easter poem is beautifully done, but I suspect it's a triumph of romance over reality, the latter being the Russian military machines cynical disregard for the value of Ukrainian lives regardless of gender or age. Sadly, the word Mariupol is likely to become synonymous with ruthless atrocity in the same way that Guernica, Dresden, Gaza and Homs have.
I'm a child of the 80s so the Beatles didn't feature in my musical upbringing. I love the version of Imagine though, magical. And the poem and the beautiful Easter egg.๐
Well I think the poem is wonderful.
What a coincidence I should be reading James Patterson's 'The Last Days of John Lennon' while coming upon your excellent article and touching poem!
Patterson's eell constructed, easy read book charts all of Lennon's life and I had just read about what you covered Steve!
People's hearts must go out to the poor souls of Ukraine.
Yes, let's wish for the miracle of peace!
And I loved your Easter egg gift.
Nothing is more appropriate than Lennon's classic song at this time!
That is a great essay, Steve, and a beaut poem. Thank you.
On another note, interesting that Brisbane gets left out of Brett Cooper's comment on the Beatles 1964 tour of Oz. They were there, and so was I. Not at the actual concert, although my mother wanted to go. I suspected she wouldn't be able to cope with all the screaming, so we went to see Roy Orbison instead.
Yeah, yeah, yeah, I'll second that emotion. It's not too big a claim to make. Those Beatles appearances did change America and the world. Thanks also for the link to Julian singing Imagine - that's beautiful. Your Easter poem is heart-rending. I think it does exactly what you hoped it would. Bravo.
Thanks for this Steve, a great read about the Fabs and a fab poem to boot, hope in the face of adversity is what makes us.
I can take or leave the Beatles (heresy, I know), though I don't doubt your claims on their behalf. Your beautiful Easter In Mariupol poem on the other hand almost moves me to tears. It's so seemingly simple yet so deeply moving. Brilliant work.
That's a tremendous poem, Steve. Well said.๐
It is Orthodox Easter in Ukraine today (one week later than in the West). Pope Francis called on Russia to observe a Holy Day ceasefire. They kept up the shelling of Mariupol even on Easter Day. For the people of Ukraine, celebration with tears today. As your poem says "Hope treads on fragments of shells."
This was interesting Steve. I suppose the Beatles' "US Invasion" helped to make all things British "cool" as well for a while. Well done with the moving poem.
I didn't know that's HOW the Beatles conquered America - clearly pivotal in historical terms and the fact their first two televised appearances are still in the top 3 ever. Your poem is deceptively simple, cleverly worked and packs an emotional punch. And I love Julian Lennon singing his dad's anthem. Thanks as always for sharing.
Just picking up on the comments about the Beatles playing in Brisbane in 1964, I asked some friends and yes, they played two nights at the Festival Hall at the end of June. My friend Eddie was a student at Queensland Uni at the time and said he queued for 2 days to get tickets.
Well done with your Mariupol poem. The enormity of what is happening across in Ukraine is difficult to process and the danger is that we all overload on the constant updates about the war and the atrocities, but you've made it up close and impactful by looking at the smaller rather than the bigger picture. It's powerful and its brilliant.
A fascinating and brilliant article as always, and as ever - a beautifully constructed poem. Those last three lines are curdling and tender, like choosing to see the glimmer of hope, the potential of beauty, a rose for all its thorns :)
a soldier and orphan holding hands
in the starkness of this earthly hell.
Hope treads on fragments of shells.
AmAzing work Steve :)
Josh
That's an excellent account of the impact The Beatles had on America, superbly written. I like the way you've tied in the contemporary (1964 that is) debate about the band rivalling Christianity in the popularity stakes. Apart from anything else, that Lennon could even make that comparison in all modesty just highlights how mind-blowing the phenomenal scale of the Fabs' success must have seemed even to them - scary in fact! As for your Easter in Mariupol poem, surely you know you've hit your remit - it's a wonderful poem.
Really enjoyed your Beatles piece. I tried to post an image but it doesn't work so will PM it to you. Great poetry too.
Easter In Mariupol - brilliant stuff Steve. ๐ Also, thanks for the link to Lennon junior singing Imagine, wonderful to hear.
Crushingly amazing words Steve! xxx
What a great blog. I love Beatles music but didn't know history or about religious arguments. Congratulations for very good poem also.
My mom was at their last ever show, San Francisco in August 1966. No one knew it was going to be the last but she said although the stadium was only half full you couldn't hear the Beatles for all the screaming. They played inside some sort of cage for their own safety and their set was over in 30 minutes. I love your poem. We pray for Ukraine.
I started reading this and had to put A Hard Day's Night on the turntable. It's a lovely essay and an apt comparison to make. Your Mariupol poem is excellent.
The Beatles and Jesus stuff was interesting. Your Easter in Mariupol poem I think is stunning. Well done. ๐
Great stuff❤️
Who doesn't love the Beatles? My American friends tell me that Paul McCartney has just embarked on a tour over there to celebrate his 80th birthday. Wow.
Your Easter poem is so moving, brilliantly done.
Great writing.
Wow Steve. What a brilliant and poignant poem. I love Julian Lennon's rendition of Imagine as well. Thank you for sharing.
I knew the Beatles had 'conquered' America, I hadn't realised the sudden manner of them doing so. And how fantastic that the viewing record still stands today (even allowing for the proliferation of viewing options). You've created something very moving with your Easter in Mariupol poem. Well done.
What a stunning poem. I see what you mean about focussing right down. So seemingly simple and yet so powerful.
50+ years on, I really don't know if Lennon has been proved right or not. Certainly way fewer people go to church than they did half a century ago (at least in the UK, I don't know about the USA) and certainly the Beatles are still the most popular group there has ever been. So maybe it's an honourable draw? Anyway, that aside, I love the poem and the Easter egg. Thank you.
I never watch the dreaded Eurovision but I did last night to see the Ukraine group play (and win!) and end their performance with an appeal to the world to save Mariupol. ๐
Heart-stopping poetry.
Post a Comment