written and posted by members of Lancashire Dead Good Poets' Society

Wednesday 26 April 2023

Tea Recipes

I know nothing about recipes. Absolutely nothing. I just looked at a few and they could all be written in a foreign language as far as I’m concerned. Which was a bit of a problem until I wondered whether the following could fit the bill.

One of my oldest friends, Anne, and I agree on a lot of things, I suppose that is why we have been friends for so long. But there is one subject on which there is a deep and uncrossable chasm between us. She insists on having her cups of tea with the milk poured in after the boiling water and I know that it should be poured in first. She now makes her own, even when she is at my place.

What? But...
I shall now put forward my evidence:

a) Dr Andrew Stapley, of Loughborough University, has said you should make your tea with the milk poured in first. He found that if you pour milk into a hot brew, the milk will heat unevenly which will cause the proteins in your milk to alter their natural quality.

His research also revealed pouring your milk into the cup before the hot water can lower the mineral content of your water and bring back the flavour to an otherwise mediocre brew.

b) Alan Mackie of Leeds University, professor of colloid chemistry in the department of food and nutrition, states that adding milk to the cup first prevents flavour loss caused by hard water.

Prof Mackie said the minerals found in hard water prevent flavour compounds forming. But milk contains proteins which lower the water’s mineral content, making your tea taste better, according to research the scientist conducted with boiling water tap manufacturer INTU.

"Flavour by and large is produced by the different compounds in tea including tannins in particular," Prof Mackie said. "The more minerals present in water the more difficult it is for these compounds to develop the flavour - resulting in the dull cuppas you get in hard water areas.

"Making tea the traditional way - steeping a bag in hot water before removing it and adding milk - results in the tannins turning into solids before they can develop the flavour properly.

"But, if the milk is added at the start of the steeping process then its proteins can bind to the tannins and other minerals in the water - preventing them from turning solid - which in turn gives you a far superior flavour."

I rest my case. But will add that whilst looking up the definitive information above I came across the following from George Orwell’s 1946 essay ‘A Nice Cup of Tea’:


‘When I look through my own recipe for the perfect cup of tea, I find no fewer than 11 outstanding points. On perhaps two of them there would be pretty general agreement, but at least four others are acutely controversial. Here are my own 11 rules, every one of which I regard as golden’. 

Note the use of the word ‘recipe’.

And totally and utterly bizarrely there is an International Standard. ISO 3103 is a standard specifying a standardized method for brewing tea, possibly sampled by the standardized methods described in ISO 1839. It was originally laid down in 1980 as BS 6008:1980 by the British Standards Institution and a revision was published in December, 2019 as ISO/NP 3103. It was produced by ISO Technical Committee 34 (Food products), Sub-Committee 8 (Tea).

Point 11) If the test involves milk, then it is added to the bowl before pouring the infused tea into it.

Going back to Orwell, he also states that the making of a cup of tea is acutely controversial and can lead to violent disputes. Therefore, I suggest the following before passing on the correct method:


How to Make the Perfect Cup of Tea 2023

WARNING
The following words may cause
Distress Anger Panic
To friends and family
Do NOT use indiscriminately

Use a plain brown half pint mug
Place one Yorkshire Gold teabag in mug
Add two teaspoonfuls of sugar
Cover the bag first with whole milk
Pour boiling water into mug
Stir vigorously with teaspoon
Press bag against side of mug
When liquid is dark brown
Put teabag in bin
Your tea is ready to enjoy








Thanks for reading, Terry Q


12 comments:

Pam Winning said...

Oh Terry, I'm with Anne on this, 100%. Always Yorkshire Teabags, and my usual mug. I'm a George Orwell fan, too, but would disagree with him, if only he were here.
Great blog, an enjoyable read. Thank you 😊

Anonymous said...

You now know why I never bother to come ‘up North’ and visit you! 🀣

terry quinn said...

Dear Pam, just between you and me.
Actually, George Orwell's 10th point in his essay was 'one should pour tea into the cup first'. But that was in 1946 and before the evidence I have presented above. I'm sure he would have changed his mind given that.
I used the Essay to prove it was a Recipe and to point to his acknowledgement that the subject is acutely controversial.
Hope you have a lovely cup this morning.

Stu Hodges said...

The trouble with tea-bags is that many are made of plastic (true)! Scientists have found that one plastic tea bag releases around 11.6 billion microplastics and 3.1 billion smaller nanoplastic particles into the cup. Those, in turn, end up in the drinker's digestive system. That's not to mention the microplastics that enter the environment when the tea-bags are binned. Some manufacturers are committed to eliminating plastics in tea-bags (PG, Pukka, Teapigs, Yorkshire). Caveat emptor!

Poppy Deveraux said...

That phrase "Making tea the traditional way - steeping a bag in hot water before removing it and adding milk..." made me hoot.🀣

Making tea in the traditional way actually involves leaf tea and a teapot (warmed first) into which boiling water is poured. Milk (if desired) comes later after the tea has brewed, rendering arguments about whether the milk or the tea goes into the cup first largely irrelevant.😊

Boz said...

How did Yorkshire tea ever get to be a thing?

Steve Rowland said...

Ha ha Terry, stirring up tea wars! Let me start by saying you got me reading Orwell again for the first time in a decade or two. I found I was in general agreement with him - 81% to be precise - regarding blend, leaf, pot, strength etc. The -19% only because I don't add milk to my tea. Even then, his argument for adding milk after pouring the tea is an empirical one - the easiest way of ensuring the right ratio of milk to tea - although I recognise modern science confutes it on grounds of good taste. Your recipe poem amused and horrified, of course (LOL). Well done.

Ben Templeton said...

I found the science around 'milk first' interesting and will give that a try, though I've also obviously been going wrong by not using a plain brown half pint mug. 😊

Debbie Laing said...

Cup not mug, milk in first, gingernut to dunk. Perfect.

Cynthia said...

I’m a total tea freak.Leaf tea in teapot and cup not mug and milk first but there are lots of teas to be drunk without milk.Stirred up nicely TerryπŸ«–

Bella Jane Barclay said...

Jackson's English Breakfast Tea - doesn't matter what time of day - brewed in a pot (don't like teabags), drunk from a big tea cup, milk in first and no sugar. I've been drinking it like that for forty years, not going to change now.

Binty said...

I wish I'd read this before Steve's blog about biscuits. Always milk first, and delighted to read someone else dunks ginger nuts. Respect.